Keep Victoria Falls Wild

Current Threats




Zambezi National Park (Zimbabwe)





Wave of Development Threatens Falls, June 2022


Zimbabwe's National Parks were originally designated as 'no permanent development' zones, with adjoining Safari Areas set aside for either consumptive tourism (hunting) or commercial concessions and leases such as tourism camps and lodges.

Overnight facilities for visitors to the Zambezi National Park, upstream of the Victoria Falls, originally included three dedicated Fishing Camps (Kandahar, Siansimba, and Mpala Jena) with flushing toilet, cold shower and sleeping shelter, and four 'minimum development' picnic camps (Chundu 1, Chundu 2, Chomunzi and Saminungu) with braai stand and bush toilet, all suitable for groups up to twelve people. Over the last decade, however, there has been a steady trend in the licensing of these public campsites as private concessions, with tourism companies developing exclusive luxury safari lodges. Ten years ago there were no private concessions within the Park.

Following the opening of the Victoria Falls River Lodge in 2012 - the first riverside concession within the Zambezi National Park - there has been a wave of commercial concessions developed along the riverside fringe within the Park, including Pioneers Camp (opened in July 2013, relaunched as Mpala Jena Camp in February 2019); Zambezi Sands River Camp (opened in October 2014 - located at the old Chomunzi Camp); the Victoria Falls Island Treehouse Lodge (opened August 2017 - located on Kandahar Island, part of the Victoria Falls River Lodge development); Chundu Island Lodge (opened in November 2017); the Old Drift Lodge (opened 2018) and Tsowa Safari Island (opened in August 2019).

The current wave of new tourism developments on riverside sites within the Zambezi National Park include Kandahar Camp (despite the fact that the site lies within the WHS 'Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone' - a strict no new development area), Chundu Camp, picnic spot 'No.14' and associated island development (see Victoria Dream development), Picnic sites 21-25 and Siansimba Camp.

Away from the river there are also a number of commercial concessions being considered within the Zambezi National Park, including a captive bird park (near the Zambezi Gate) and half a dozen lodge developments, including one with a proposed conference centre facility and 'solar farm' (see More Proposals).


Tourism concessions within the Zambezi and Victoria Falls National Parks

Map showing tourism concessions within the Zambezi and Victoria Falls National Parks
(existing - green, proposed - red)
(adapted from 2024 Victoria Falls/Zambezi National Park Management Plan, p.23)
[click image for larger view].


Negative Impacts


Speaking in February 2021 in relation to negative public reaction to the development of the Siansimba Camp Site, Dr Fulton Mangwanya, Director-General of the Zimbabwe National Park and Wildlife Authority, outlined plans to 'upgrade' four sites in the Park 'so that the public can go and actually enjoy' them.

"What we are doing in Victoria Falls - I have had some complaints - we have got about twenty-five picnic sites along Zambezi River. I am planning to upgrade four of these sites to start with and these are Siansimba, and Kandahar, site four and site ten, so that the public can go and actually enjoy it, because it's supposed to be like that. You know, according to our constitution the public are supposed to enjoy some of these facilities that we have, so I am going to do that by the end of the year, I'll have renovated some of these places, revamped them so that they come and see. And wherever there are some leases, the leases are not privatised for Christ's sake - public is allowed to go in and enjoy seeing animals and enjoy seeing the park even if there are some leases. So I think there is a misconception that I'd like to correct." (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, February 2021b)

But the truth of the matter is that public visitors to the National Park will not be allowed access to the river in areas which are developed as commercial safari camps. Each development stretches over one kilometre of riverside fringe, and the sites developed are all those which have been selected as picnic spots and camp sites because of their scenic value. Independent visitors to the Park will be excluded access to these sites.



'No Entry' signs

'No Entry' signs from Zambezi National Park concessions
(ZPWMA, May 2022).

Local residents have previously expressed concern over the development of these sites as exclusive lodges which will no doubt be priced towards international visitors.

"How will we attract local and regional visitors to the Park if these sites are all private concessions aimed and priced at international tourists? How will we educate tomorrow's decision makers and defenders of our natural heritage to support their National Parks and respect wildlife if they have never had the opportunity to experience these places?" (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, February 2021a)

The concessions will also exclude independent safari companies from access to prime viewpoints and campsites, disadvantaging local companies and diminishing the visitor experience for all.

No new visitor facilities have been developed within the park to compensate for the lost facilities for general visitors, leaving no rest sites, toilet or camp facilities available for independent visitors to use.

There are additional concerns over the limited road infrastructure in the Park - essentially a single riverside drive extending upriver with short loop roads - and its ability to cope with the increased numbers of safari vehicles, especially in consideration of the rapidly reducing number of picnic and other sites which will be available for use. These new concessions will therefore also negatively affect the visitor experience for the existing lodge developments in the Park.

Vehicle entry to the Zambezi National Park should be limited to a maximum carrying capacity, calculated by the capacity of the road network.

"About five kilometres of game viewing road is needed for each visitor vehicle... The number of vehicles allowed into a park at any one time is restricted to the capacity of the road network, while limitations on the types and sizes of vehicles are dictated by standards of road construction, visitor safety and disturbance to animals." (Child, Heath and Moore, 1989)

The excessive development of commercial concessions within the fragile riverside ecology of the Zambezi National Park also risks compromising the ecological integrity of the riverine forest fringe and permanently damaging their wildlife and scenic value (see The Fragile Forest Fringe).

No Disclosure, Limited Benefits


At a recent National Park planning meeting, held with local stakeholders at the Victoria Falls on 9th May 2022, Park representatives declined the opportunity to present further information on the wave of new tourism development proposals currently threatening the Falls and surrounding areas, indicating that "lease allocations will be discussed at a different forum" (ZPWMA, May 2022). This was in the face of widespread criticism from stakeholders on lack of transparency in the allocation of concessions, substandard ESIA reports and limited public disclosure and stakeholder consultation.

In addition to all these concerns there appear to be limited financial benefits to National Parks in regard to concessions, indicating that the concessions are being leased far too cheaply. An example given at the recent Park planning meeting suggested that a small independent operator offering three game drives per day with an average of five clients would over a year contribute more to National Parks than the annual lease fee for the Wild Horizon's Estate (and which includes visitor fees), a concession occupying the majority of the Victoria Falls National Park downstream of the Falls and on which the operators have constructed three camps accommodating close to 100 clients (ZPWMA, May 2022, p.65/68).

It appears that by not going through due public tender processes, with full disclosure and financial transparency, National Parks are accepting agreements directly with operators at disadvantageous terms - to themselves.



Victoria Falls

Development pressures - Victoria Falls upstream river corridor (upper section, above, and lower section, below). Existing developments in white, new/proposed developments in red.


Victoria Falls




Current Threats


Riverside tourism development threats within the Zambezi National Park area of the UNESCO World Heritage Site, listed running upstream from main riverside road entry point 6 km above Falls.

Malachite Suites (WHS)

Kandahar Camp (WHS)

Upstream developments:

Victoria Dream Island

Picnic Sites 21-25

Chundu Camp

More Proposals



See here for proposed developments affecting the area of the UNESCO World Heritage Site within the Victoria Falls National Park.

See here for proposed developments within the Victoria Falls City Council, either directly adjoing World Heritage Site or within surrounding Buffer Zone area.

See here for developments threats affecting the area of the UNESCO World Heritage Site within the Mosi-oa-Tunya National Park (Zambia).




References


Links to external sites or pdf downloads, open in a new window.

Child, Heath and Moore (1989) Tourism to National Parks in Zimbabwe 1969-1989. Proceedings of the Geographical Association of Rhodesia. No.20, p53-78.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (February 2021a) Campaign to Save Siansimba Gains Momentum.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (February 2021b) ZimParks Under Pressure.

Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority (May 2022) ZPWMA VF-ZNP Planning Meeting May 2022 (pdf download [8mb], opens in a new window)