Keep Victoria Falls Wild

Conservation and Development of the Victoria Falls




Controversial Concessions

Riverside Tree Lodge Proposal

Parks Under Pressure

Sian Simba River Lodge

Riverside Developments

Cataract Island Tours

Riverside Restaurant

Riverside Bar

A New Threat

The Six Senses Sanctuary

Legal Challenge

Reactive Statement

Opposing Affidavit

Confused Consultants

No Disclosure

The Baines Restaurant

Second Legal Challenge Raised (January 2025)

Developers Attempt to Silence Campaigner




The following text has been adapted (with permission) from

'Paradise Lost? Conservation and Development of the Victoria Falls (1900-2025)',

researched and written by Peter Roberts and published in February 2026





Controversial Concessions


In January 2021 it was announced that Sansimba (also widely spelt Siansimba), one of only two remaining undeveloped overnight campsites within the south-bank Zambezi National Park and popular with local residents and independent wildlife and fishing tours operators, was to be developed as a private concession, together with an associated development at a pristine wilderness site known as Siansimba Springs.

“Tusker Investments (Pvt) Ltd t/a Sansimba River Lodge, a duly registered Zimbabwean company, intends to establish a safari camp in the Zambezi National Park. The company has secured a lease from the Parks and Wildlife Management Authority, to lease a portion of the Zambezi National Park, measuring about 0.5 km², located at the confluence of Sansimba River and the Zambezi River. The proposed camp will be mainly for photographic safari, picnics, bush dinners and game drives. The camp will result in the construction of semi-permanent tourist accommodation facilities with a capacity to hold not more than 24 beds. It will also see the establishment of supporting infrastructure such as site offices, ablution facilities, a central communal area which will be used as a dining or cooking area and also some staff quarters, accommodating up to 6 staff. All structures at the camp will be semi-permanent in the forms of tents.” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 17th February 2021)

Located within the Zambezi National Park, about 35 kilometres upstream of the Victoria Falls, Siansimba (originally spelt Sansimba) was one of three overnight fishing camps (Kandahar, Siansimba, and Mpala Jena) and four ‘minimal development’ picnic camps (Chundu 1, Chundu 2, Chomunzi and Saminungu) originally established in the 1960s and suitable for groups up to twelve people. The sites were available to be booked by anyone visiting the Park, either independently or through organised tour operators and guides and popular with multi-day canoe safaris. Over the last decade, however, there has been a steady trend in the licensing of these sites as private concessions, with tourism companies developing exclusive luxury safari lodges. Mpala Jena was developed as a private concession in 2013, while it subsequently also emerged that the remaining overnight camp, Kandahar Camp, had also been allocated as a concession, despite being located within the boundaries of the WHS HESZ.

The proposal received widespread negative criticism from local residents and stakeholders, especially small independent tourism operators, who yet again faced loosing access to a popular camping site and further restricting access to the best and most beautiful areas of the Park for the exclusive use of lodge guests. A ‘Save Siansimba’ campaign group was created by local residents appealing for the campsite to remain open to the public, available to all visitors.


Riverside Tree Lodge Proposal


The development of a “24 bed semi-permanent tented tree lodge” located along a two kilometre stretch the south-bank riverine fringe surrounding the Elephant Hills Golf Course, protected as part of the Victoria Falls National Park and World Heritage Site HESZ, was first disclosed to local residents when heavy machinery and materials appeared along Zambezi Drive (close to the Big Tree) in December 2020. A post on a local Facebook group, Victoria Falls EnviroWatch, in December 2020 showed photographs of piles of road building materials which had arrived at the location, quoting a National Park source confirming the development.

“I met with the Area manager of national parks Victoria Falls this morning to ask about the development in front of the Golf course. He has confirmed that the development is a 24 bed semi-permanent tented tree lodge. He confirms that thorough EIA’s have been done that address the concerns of the animal corridors. The lodge is unfenced and will allow animals to continue to traverse through that area” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 8th February 2021)

While claiming that a thorough EIA had been completed for the proposal, there was no public disclosure or wider stakeholder consultation (core elements of the EIA process).

A riverside access road, connecting Zambezi Drive upstream to the commercial jetty sites and boat club, was cut through the site in early 2021 (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 8th February 2021). Satellite images from 2022 show the new dirt road running through this section, connecting Big Tree area upstream to the river jetty sites. The front-loader vehicle used in the work was left abandoned along Zambezi Drive roadside for three and a half years before being removed.


Victoria Falls Six Senses Tree Lodge Development

Road infrastructure development for the Victoria Falls Six Senses 'Sanctuary' Riverside Lodge development [click for larger view]


The site is located within the Victoria Falls National Park and World Heritage Site HESZ according to the 2007 and 2016 Joint Management Plan text descriptions, but incorrectly shown in the 2016 and 2020 management zonation maps as being within the MESZ. The area is also within the Ramsar Site and Important Bird Area. It was reported that National Parks had agreed a 75-year concession with House of Chinhara Hospitality Ltd. for the site at a reported annual lease fee of US$1 million (ZPWMA, October 2023, p.57).

The proposal was not identified in 2020 map of proposed developments presented in the 2020 State of Conservation Report (State Parties, 2020) and there has been no disclosure of this development in subsequent State of Conservation Reports.


Parks Under Pressure


Speaking in February 2021 in relation to negative public reaction to the proposal, Dr Fulton Mangwanya, Director-General of the Zimbabwe National Park and Wildlife Authority, outlined plans to ‘upgrade’ four sites in the Park, including Kandahar Camp - the last remaining overnight campsite available within the Park and despite the area being located within the WHS HESZ, a zone which permits no new development.

“What we are doing in Victoria Falls - I have had some complaints - we have got about twenty-five picnic sites along Zambezi River. I am planning to upgrade four of these sites to start with and these are Siansimba, and Kandahar, site four and site ten, so that the public can go and actually enjoy it, because it’s supposed to be like that. You know, according to our constitution the public are supposed to enjoy some of these facilities that we have, so I am going to do that by the end of the year, I’ll have renovated some of these places, revamped them so that they come and see. And wherever there are some leases, the leases are not privatised for Christ’s sake - public is allowed to go in and enjoy seeing animals and enjoy seeing the park even if there are some leases. So I think there is a misconception that I’d like to correct.” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 25th February 2021)

But the truth of the matter is that visitors to the National Park will not be allowed access to the river in areas which are developed as commercial safari camps unless they are guests of that particular lodge. Each development stretches over one kilometre of riverside fringe, and the sites developed are all those which have been selected as picnic spots and camp sites because of their scenic value.


Sian Simba River Lodge


The upstream Sian Simba River Lodge opened in August 2022, offering 12 tented twin or double rooms, located 35 kilometres upstream of the Falls within the Zambezi National Park. Despite the ESIA stakeholder disclosure clearly stating that “all structures at the camp will be semi-permanent in the forms of tents” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 17th February 2021), the main lodge building was constructed in brick and cement and the grounds extensively landscaped with pathways and lawns. The new development has opened its restaurant for day visitors into the park, as well as offering overnight camping facilities.


Zambezi National Park Sian Simba River Lodge

Sian Simba River Lodge Development (2025)



Riverside Developments


During 2022 controversial new tourism developments were established along the south-bank Zambezi Drive, just upstream of the Falls and within the upstream river extension of the Victoria Falls National Park and World Heritage Site HESZ, raising further concerns over the Park Authority’s management of the Victoria Falls. Permitted developments within National Park concessions are restricted to semi-permanent infrastructure, yet these new developments, along with other recent concession developments (including the Sian Simba River Lodge and the redeveloped Lookout Cafe) have been constructed partially in brick and cement (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, August 2023).

The upstream river corridor and riverside fringe above the Victoria Falls is protected for 6 kilometres above the Falls as part of the Victoria Falls National Park, UNESCO World Heritage Site, Ramsar Site and Important Bird Area. The area is covered under the HESZ ‘no new development’ zone and identified as under the 1975 Victoria Falls Outline Plan as ‘restricted permanently’ from new development. Additionally a 150 metre wide strip extending from the riverbank is also supposedly protected under planning guidelines from damaging developments (UNESCO, 2010).

The riverine forest fringe is noted for its importance to wildlife and wider scenic value. The vulnerability of this habitat is recognised in the 1996 Plan (IUCN, 1996b, p.30) and both the 2007 and 2016 Joint Management Plans (State Parties, 2007; 2016b, p.18-9). Any development within this zone threatens to permanently degrade the fragile natural ecology and biodiversity value of the area, yet these tourism developments have been allowed without due disclosure to UNESCO.


Cataract Island Tours


Despite the Committee’s specific request for an ESIA and State Parties assurances to notify the Committee in advance of any new development in regard to this proposal in 2017 (World Heritage Committee, 2017), tours to Cataract Island were launched by Zambezi Crescent, managers of the Victoria Falls River Lodge, in early 2022, with no further disclosure or notification. It has since become evident that the concession to utilise the island was secured by the operator immediately following the controversy over the Wild Horizons proposal to utilise the island in 2016, rejected by the company in the face of wide-spread opposition.

The tours to Cataract Island, including swimming in the natural plunge pools on the lip of the Falls (as per the popular tours to Livingstone Island and the Devil’s Pool operated from the Zambian side), were officially launched in April 2022 with a new website and social media campaign, but without public or local stakeholder disclosure and consultation, no supporting Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (specifically requested by UNESCO in 2017) and without notifying UNESCO (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 8th June 2022).

“A fully guided experience including a short boat trip across the calm waters of the channel to Cataract Island. Once disembarked, a guided tour of the Island follows, including time to explore the new section of Victoria Falls that is busy forming. Enjoy plenty of free time for optional swimming in the warm, clear pools on the face of the Falls, or to explore some of the most spectacular scenery that nature has to offer.” (Zambezi Crescent, 2022)

Despite assuring UNESCO that it would update the World Heritage Committee of all new developments on the ground, made in response to a specific request from the Committee for an ESIA in relation to the utilisation of the island for tourism (World Heritage Committee, 2017) the operator has continued to utilise the island for as an exclusive option for their Victoria Falls River Lodge clients throughout this period.

The protected refuge of Cataract Island was the last remaining area of the Falls Rainforest untouched by modern tourist foot-fall and associated trampling impacts on the fragile ground flora and disturbance to wildlife such as nesting birds. This fragile environment, the rich vegetation zone immediately surrounding the Falls and supported by the spray from the Falls, nourishes a diverse flora of rare ground plants and shrubs, highly vulnerable to disturbance. The operation of tours on the island will result in compaction of the soil layer and formation of pathways, resulting in the fragmentation and degradation of the local ecology and biodiversity.

There has been no ESIA and no biological base-line surveying of the flora against which to measure the future ecological impacts of these activities.


Riverside Restaurant


In April 2022 work started clearing bush, scrub and trees from a riverside site just above the Devil’s Cataract, outside the fenced Victoria Falls visitor area but within the upstream river extension of the VFNP and WHS, for a rumoured restaurant development.

In June the developers, Scanner Investments (Pvt) Ltd (trading as Victoria Falls Investments), claimed that a full ESIA had been completed for the proposal, yet there had been no public disclosure or open stakeholder consultation on the proposal, core elements of the ESIA process. It was also claimed that the development was within the ‘Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ (MESZ) of the World Heritage Site, and therefore an allowed development. It is clear, however, that the text descriptions of the management zones presented in both the 2007 and 2016 Joint Management Plans include this section riverside fringe within the ‘Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ (HESZ) which allows no new development. As with the recently launched Cataract Island tours there has also been no formal disclosure on this proposal to UNESCO. The proposal is not identified in the 2020 map of proposed developments presented in the 2020 State of Conservation report (State Parties, 2020), nor is there any reference to it in the 2021 State of Conservation Report (State Parties, 2022).

The construction caused huge local controversy and widespread negative social media reaction, including another online petition against the over-development of the Falls, including the launch of Cataract Island tours (and which gained close to 20,500 signatures by the end of August 2023).

In the second half of June 2022 a container unit arrived on the site followed by construction materials in October.


Baines Restaurant Victoria Falls Zambezi Drive

Site of proposed riverside restaurant, Zambezi Drive, October 2022
[click for larger view]



Riverside Bar


Following attempts to control access to the river above the Falls in 2018, the Zimbabwe Park Authority has slowly but steadily developed formalised facilities at the site along Zambezi Drive, the development becoming known as the 'Rock Pool'. First revealed with the construction of a small brick building which appeared in early in 2022, further structures have since been developed, including associated landscaped lawns and car parking areas just upstream from the controversial restaurant development and again located within the HESZ ‘no development zone.’

There has been no public disclosure or stakeholder consultation regarding these developments or specific disclosure via the State of Conservation Reports, although the developments follow the trail of the bathing pool in 2018 at the same location. The vague reference to formalising the use of sites along Zambezi Drive was repeated in the 2020 State of Conservation report, but again with no further details.

“The project seeks to regularize and formalize the use of an area popular with the local community while addressing the environmental issues relating to the site, including littering and uncontrolled access.” (State Parties, 2020, p.19)

The plans appear to be designed to raise income and control free access to the river above the Falls by the local community. The development opened in December 2022, offering bar, picnic and braai (barbecue) facilities. Complaints were raised by residents over the number of people (up to 200) and excessive number of vehicles gathered along Zambezi Drive, and associated noise pollution, with a loud-speaker system and bar operating until late into the evening (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, September 2023).


Victoria Falls Zambezi Drive

Site of proposed riverside restaurant, Zambezi Drive, October 2022
[click for larger view]


Late night special events were promoted over holiday weekends through 2023 under the National Park mantra ‘In Harmony with Nature.’ In this case disharmony would be more accurate. As with the other riverside developments there are concerns over the disposal of waste (including sanitary) as well as noise and light pollution and impacts from physical disturbanceand degradation of the wider area of the riverine fringe.


A New Threat


The development of the Council-controlled riverside stand between A’Zambezi and Palm River Lodges was first publicised in December 2020:

“The proposed hotel will spot 200 keys with 120 standard rooms, 48 deluxe rooms, 30 suites, and two presidential, making it an upper upscale scale brand in the same benchmark with Victoria Falls Hotel, Ilala Lodge, A’Zambezi River Lodge, Africa Albida Lodges (Safari Lodge, Safari Club, Safari Suites). The land is aptly situated on the Zambezi River frontage, making it a premium destination for tourists. The river fronting location could be an exclusive offering in Victoria Falls as opposed to many competitors that do not benefit from river views, access to the river offers the potential for other revenues streams (cruises and water activities).” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 26th December 2020)


Proposed Tourism Developments

Vision for the 'Victoria Falls Resort'


In late June 2022 Victoria Falls City Council (VFCC) announced a ‘massive’ new riverside hotel and conference centre development, the Victoria Falls Resort, to be jointly developed with Lamcent Capital (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 28th June 2022). The US$50 million development is planned to have more than 100 rooms. The three-story building shown in concept designs dominates the site and surroundings, rising above the tree level (a long held planning restriction) and dwarfing the existing neighbouring developments.

As with other stands along this section of the river above the Falls, the riverine fringe is protected as part of the Victoria Falls National Park and World Heritage Site HESZ. The main part of the plot, however, is Council controlled. This stand, as with others along this section of the river should be protected by the 500 metre Buffer Zone, as shown in the 2007 plan management zone map (State Parties, 2007, p.38). This Buffer Zone was amended in the 2016 plan, without explanation or justification, and removed from covering this section of the WHS - and thus exposing this vulnerable section of the river to unsuitable developments such as this. It needs to be re-instated as a matter of urgency.


The Six Senses Sanctuary


In September 2022 it was announced that House of Chinhara Hospitality had signed a management agreement with the InterContinental Hotel Group to manage their proposed riverside ‘tree lodge’ development under its exclusive Six Senses brand. The group had unsuccessfully courted the Marriott Hotel Group in March 2019 (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 20th March 2019). Despite the original EIA document approval reportedly being only for 12 units (24 beds), the developers were now promoting a 57-room (114 bed) five star luxury lodge and spar with six additional houseboats.

“The Sanctuary - Princess Islands Riverside Tree Top Lodge - The RareEARTH Sanctuary is managed by the magnificent Six Senses Hotels (part of the spectacular IHG Group) and is designed as a 57-room 5 star+ luxury lodge and spa, plus 6 luxury houseboats, one of which will be a floating spa-boat, a traditional wooden gulet, revamped for the ultimate African Spa-Experience. This site comprises a roughly 40-hectare parcel of land within the boundaries of the Victoria Falls National Park. Specifically, this site lies between the Elephant Hills Golf Course and the banks of the Zambezi River, overlooking the Princess Islands. From the site, the water spray of Victoria Falls is clearly visible... The... Riverside property is subject to a 25-year renewable lease.” (InterContinental Hotel Group, September 2022)

The proposed site is within the Victoria Falls National Park upstream river corridor and WHS Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone (HESZ) or ‘no new development zone’ according to the 2007 and 2016 Joint Management Plan text descriptions.

Supporting concept design images for the riverside ‘Sanctuary’ show a sprawling riverside development, highly visible from the river and apparently constructed in permanent materials, with concrete piers supporting the ‘tree lodge’ structures. The supporting media statement originally released indicated that the development was ‘slated to open in 2025,’ subsequently amended to 2030.


Six Senses Sanctuary Victoria Falls Tree Lodge Development

Six Senses Sanctuary Victoria Falls Tree Lodges concept design
[click for larger view]


A second hotel development, the Kutanga Qala Hotel, is also being promoted by House of Chinhara Hospitality, located on a 1.15 ha (11,500 m²) site along Livingstone Way and to be managed as part of the exclusive Vignette Collection, a luxury brand again marketed under the InterContinental Hotel Group. The 100-room (200-bed) development is designed to resemble a Palazzo, inspired by Great Zimbabwe, and includes a Wellness Centre and Spa. The hotel’s name, Kutanga Qala, means ‘The Beginning of the Beginning’ in Shona(a language not even native to the region).


Legal Challenge


At the end of July 2022 it was reported in the Zimbabwe Independent that a group of concerned local residents had presented a legal appeal against the use of Cataract Island for tourism and development of riverside developments within the National Park and WHS (Zimbabwe Independent, 29th July 2022). The Urgent Application (HC 3797/22), filed on 13th May, cited Scanner Investments/Victoria Falls Investments (riverside restaurant development); Adage Success/Zambezi Crescent (managers of the Victoria Falls River Lodge and operators of the controversial Cataract Island tours); the Zimbabwe National Parks and Wildlife Management Authority for authorizing such questionable leases; the Procurement Regulatory Authority of Zimbabwe for allowing a flawed tender process; and the Environmental Management Agency for allowing a fundamentally flawed Environmental Impact Studies. The application, led by local resident Larry Norton, detailed:

“The purpose of this application is to prevent the development of commercial interest at the cataract and rainforest sites, which development would only suit the commercial operators and would negatively impact on the global aesthetic perspective of the Falls. It is clear and simple to note how the aesthetics of this historic and pristine site would be detrimentally affected. The risk is too great to the applicants and the Zimbabwean public as regards a crucial environmental area of our country, and accordingly, this application is filed in the public interest...

“I further submit that the allocation of Cataract [Island] to the first respondent and rainforest to the second respondent has significant and material effects as regards the future and rights of the public of Zimbabwe and notably constitute a genuine threat to the preservation of the Victoria Falls as a World Heritage Site.

“In essence, therefore, the process of the law, and the privileges granted to Zimbabweans have been flouted by the third respondent (Parks and Wildlife Authority) and other authorities involved in the granting of the concessions. The alleged permits cannot be taken on review as no such permits have been evidenced or tendered. The entire process is being sought to be carried out in a clandestine manner.”

The applicants submitted that no commercial enterprises are allowed on Cataract Island, which is protected within the VFNP and WHS as a wild refuge free from human disturbance, and that new developments along the riverbank were also prohibited, questioning how such licenses could be lawfully issued.

“The applicants bring the present application for the respondents to confirm whether or not any lawful permit as regards two commercial sites in Victoria Falls have been issued and to provide written reasons as regards same and to confirm whether all due processes were complied with as contemplated with the Administration of Justice Act.” (Zimbabwe Independent, 29th July 2022)

In a subsequent follow-up article it was reported that the Environmental Management Agency had confirmed approval for the restaurant development, claiming the stakeholder consultation included the ‘UNESCO local office.’

“EMA spokesperson Amkela Sidange told the Independent that Scanner Investments had been issued with an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) certificate after weighing submissions made by key stakeholders including the UNESCO local office. ‘Scanner has an EIA certificate whose approval came with recommendations from landowners and relevant stakeholders who include the local UNESCO office,’ she said this week.” (Zimbabwe Independent, 5th August 2022)

There has been no public statement in support of the development by the UNESCO Regional Office. It is believed that the EMA issued the EIA certificate of approval for the development on the on the basis of the false claim that the site of the development is within the MESZ. The restaurant development is without doubt, however, located in the HESZ ‘red zone’ which prohibits all new infrastructure development.

The legal case should have been dealt with by the courts in a matter of days. Nearly four years later it still remains unheard and unresolved, with the National Park Authority still, unbelievably, maintaining the site is within the MESZ and the courts unwilling to rule for, or against, the development.


Reactive Statement


In early June and in response to the initial legal challenge, Victoria Falls Investments released a public statement on the riverside restaurant development:

“Victoria Falls Investments has obtained a lease from Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority to build and operate an upmarket restaurant on the banks of the Zambezi River. This new restaurant will add a unique and memorable experience to all tourists who visit the City of Victoria Falls. Victoria Falls Investments has noted various comments and statements circulating online regarding our development and we would like to ensure that the correct information and facts are known to all stakeholders of Victoria Falls.

“The site located within UNESCO deemed Orange Zone of the World Heritage plan and is fully compliant with all UNESCO zone regulations. The Orange zone, according the World Heritage Plan, allows for the development of ‘semi-permanent structures such as restaurants, lodges, jetty sites, etc.’ within its boundaries. Thus there are no breaches of the UNESCO World Heritage plans and thus no threat to the World Heritage status of the Victoria Falls.” (Victoria Falls Investments, June 2022)

The assertion by the developers that this site is within the ‘Orange’ management zone is incorrect. While there is no ‘Orange’ zone, their comments indicate they are referring to the Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone (MESZ), marked in yellow on maps presented to UNESCO. The text of the 2016-2021 Joint Plan clearly specifies that the riverine fringe is covered within the Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone (Block 6). The supporting map (State Parties, 2016b, p.27) correctly reflects this text description, showing the yellow MESZ (Block 7) to the west of Zambezi Drive road and the red HESZ (Block 6) covering the riverine fringe/strip and river itself.

For the upstream riverine fringe, arguably one of the most important ecological features of the Falls environment, to be in anything other than the ‘Highly Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ would be a significant shortcoming in the administration and management of the WHS. For it to be within the ‘Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone’ - the same zone as the rail and road transport corridor and visitor car parking area - would be a serious neglect of Parks core conservation aims and its legal and international obligations under the 1972 World Heritage Convention.

The developers also claimed that the design of the development includes ‘only semi-permanent (removable) structures.’

“Design features only semi-permanent (removable) structures as per regulations.” (Victoria Falls Investments, June 2022)

This statement at variance with the information presented in their EIA document, which specifies the use of brick, stone and concrete. Brick and concrete structures are permanent, not semi-permanent, structures and thus not only not allowed by Parks own regulations but also prohibited under the WHS Joint Management Plan within both the HESZ and MESZ.

Finally the developers claimed:

“The development will be unique and upmarket attraction that will enhance the city’s current offerings and our aim is to spark renewed interest in the appeal of the city on the international and local tourism markets alike.” (Victoria Falls Investments, June 2022)

In fact the development has resulted in widespread negative national, regional and international media publicity on the Falls (The Times, 14th May 2022), and will continue to do so until the fact of its construction within the WHS HESZ is recognised.


Opposing Affidavit


In response to the legal challenge, the developer launched their own opposing affidavit, supplying the court with the supporting paperwork regarding their development, including details of the concession agreement with National Parks and their EIA document, as well as supporting letters and maps (Scanner Investments, July 2022).

Documents presented by the developer indicate the National Park Authority as the source of the error in regard to the management zonation of the WHS. In a letter dated 22nd June 2021 from Dr F U Mangwanya, Director General for the Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority incorrectly stating that the site of the proposed development was within the MESZ, semi-permanent and therefore a permitted development (ZPWMA, June 2021a).

“The construction of a semi-permanent restaurant is provided for in the Joint Integrated Management Plan since the proposed development area is under the Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone.” (ZPWMA, June 2021a)

A supporting document to the Director-General’s June 2021 letter, titled ‘Guidelines for the Establishment of New Semi-Permanent Structures in the Mosi-oa-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Property’ (ZPWMA, June 2021b) was drawn up internally by ZimParks. The document incorrectly identifies the site of the restaurant development within the MESZ of the VF WHS. The supporting document concludes by appearing to suggest the deliberate manipulation and exploitation of perceived weaknesses in the 2016 JIMP document:

“In conclusion, the onus is on us as an organization to consider having the restaurant or not. The decision is an outcome on an interplay and balance of trade-offs between:

“(a) prioritisation of commercial pursuits vis a vis the dictates [diktats] of the WHS,

“(b) the dominance and manipulation of the gray [sic] area or void or conflict between the Joint Integrated Management Plan (JIMP) for the transboundary Mosi-oa-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Property (MoT/VFWHP) (2016-2021) and the other WHC documents.” (ZPWMA, June 2021b)

The twenty-five year lease agreement for the site between National Parks and Scanner Investments (Pvt) Ltd (trading as Victoria Falls Investments) was signed in August 2021. The concession site is identified as covering 7,282 square metres and limits the capacity of the completed development as 150 guests.


Confused Consultants


Documents presented by the developer of the riverside restaurant to the Zimbabwean High Court as part of the legal challenge against the development included the EIA document prepared for the project, conducted by Environmental Guardians Services (Pvt) Ltd, and dated August 2021.

Significantly the document is inconsistent as to whether the site of the development was within the WHS, the report making five incorrect references to the location being outside of the WHS (varying from being adjacent to up to 2-3 km away) and only one correct reference to the site being located within the WHS, but critically incorrectly identified as being within the Medium Ecologically Sensitive Zone (Environmental Guardian Services, 2021; Keep Victoria Falls Wild, August 2023).

Despite these fundamental errors, the Environmental Management Agency issued a EIA certificate for the development in December 2021.


No Disclosure


Part of the EIA process is public disclosure of the development, yet there was no disclosure or stakeholder review, with the developers claiming that a few private discussions with a handful of selected residents represented full public disclosure.

“The 2nd Respondent [Scanner Investments] consulted ‘Victoria Falls EnviroWatch’ on 1st July 2021. This is a legally registered Trust, with a board of Trustees who represent the community of Victoria Falls on Environment issues. To suggest that no public consultations were made is therefore mischievous and misguided.” (Scanner Investments, 2022, p.11)

The developer did not meet with VFEW - they met with one individual, Tony Peel, who is chairman of VFEW, but the meeting was private and no details of the development were made public.

The whole point of a public disclosure process is to reach members of the community who the developers may not be aware of. Principle 7 of the IUCN World Heritage Advice Note: Environmental Assessment (2013) on World Heritage Impact Assessment Principles advises “The assessment must be publicly disclosed and subject to thorough public consultation at different stages” before going on to specify including the local community (IUCN, 2013, p.6). Annex 2, point 7 of the same document details:

“The assessment should be publicly disclosed as early as possible and subject to thorough consultation via appropriate means, including public meetings, online, in local languages as appropriate.” (IUCN, 2013, p.16)

If the developers had conducted due public disclosure, as required by the UNESCO guidelines (and which they are legally obliged to follow under the terms and conditions of their concession with National Parks), they may have discovered that their site is actually within the HESZ of the WHS which prohibits all new infrastructure development.

Photographs from October 2022 show that despite the concerns over the future of the WHS and ongoing legal case against the development construction still continued at the site.


The Baines Restaurant


Despite all the legal challenge to the riverside developments on the south bank, construction of the riverside restaurant immediately above the Falls continued into 2023. The completed development was quietly opened under the name of the Baines Restaurant in mid-2023 (Keep Victoria Falls Wild, August 2023).

In their June 2022 statement the developer had claimed that the development would not be visible from viewpoints within the Victoria Falls visitor park.

“Structures will not be seen from the Victoria Falls viewing points and will blend into the natural surroundings of the river bank, being offset from the river.” (Victoria Falls Investments, June 2022)

Photographs from August 2023, however, show light pollution from the restaurant clearly intruding over the view of the Devil’s Cataract when viewed from the Rainforest.


Baines Restaurant Victoria Falls

Lights from the newly constructed Baines Restaurant intrude
over the view of the Devil's Cataract in a picture
taken at night on a special tour to experience the lunar rainbow
[click for larger view]



Second Legal Challenge Raised (January 2025)


In January 2025, frustrated at delays to their original legal challenge, and following the confirmation of the riverine fringe as being within the HESZ, a second legal case (HCH 114/25) was raised by local residents specifically aimed at resolving the legal impasse regarding the Baines Restaurant development. This second case cited Scanner investments (Baines Restaurant), Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority, Barbara Rwodzi, the Minister of Tourism and Sithembiso Nyoni, the Minister of Environment.

“Renowned wildlife painter Larry Benjamin Norton has filed a fresh High Court application seeking the demolition of Baines Restaurant, arguing that it was constructed in a restricted area within the precincts of Victoria Falls... He seeks to have the lease agreement between ZimParks and Scanner Investments declared null and void and demands the demolition of Baines Restaurant within 30 days from the court’s ruling.” (Zimbabwe Independent, 7th February 2025)

It is understood that the two Ministers agreed to review the situation, but deferred action pending the verdict of the initial court proceedings.


Developers Attempt to Silence Campaigner


In a retaliatory move Scanner Investments filed a defamation and damages claim against Mr Norton for US$2.2 million on 16th May 2025 (HCH2294/25), still claiming their development was within the permitted MESZ and claiming that Norton’s allegations had severely harmed the reputation and business prospects of the now fully operational restaurant (Zimbabwe Independent, 30th May 2025).

The summons detailed:

“a) An order interdicting the Defendant from:

“i) spreading malicious falsehoods and defamatory information about the Baines Restaurant, specifically that it was built in the prohibited red zone on construction.

ii) issuing out statements, interviews, petitions and letters on any forum de- campaigning the Baines Restaurant, on the false basis that it was established without following due process.

“b) An order for the payment of US2,220,000 (two millions, two hundred and twenty thousand United States Dollars), or the equivalent thereof in ZIG at the prevailing bank rate in damages and in historical, current and future losses of business occasioned by the falsehoods published by the Defendant.” (Zimbabwe High Court, 16th May 2025)

Mr Norton commented:

“On 20th May 2025, I received notice that I was being sued for US$2,220 million (or ZIG equivalent) by Scanner Investments P/L, the developers who built and operate the legally disputed Baines Restaurant, sited in the riverine fringe...

“My ardent battle here has been to try to protect and preserve the Victoria Falls World Heritage Site for future generations. That is why I have spoken out and pursued legal avenues to ensure that the law and due process are followed... My lawyers have instructions to defend the matter as all suggestions of falsehood and malice are not true. I now leave the issue in their hands as I wait for the law to take its course.” (Zimbabwe Independent, 30th May 2025)

Three years after the original Urgent Application in relation to this development the Zimbabwe legal process is still yet to return a verdict on the case. The developers continue to maintain that the Baines restaurant is located within the permitted ‘MESZ,’ despite the wealth of evidence indicating otherwise. The irony of their claim for damages is that they are the ones who have stalled and frustrated the original legal case at every step, dragging the process out over several years.




Next: The 2024 Park Management Plan




References


Links to external sites or pdf downloads, open in a new window.


Environmental Guardian Services (2021) Environmental Impact Assessment Report for Scanner Investments. August 2021. (part of Scanner Investments documents, July 2022)

InterContinental Hotel Group (September 2022) Six Senses Victoria Falls to Offer Wildlife Lovers Stilted Eco-Lodges on the Zambezi. Media Release, September 2022.

IUCN (1996b) Strategic Environmental Assessment of Developments Around Victoria Falls, Volume 1: Strategic Environmental Assessment Report. IUCN Regional Office for Southern Africa.

IUCN (2013) World Heritage Advice Note: Environmental Assessment 7th June 2013 (external link, opens in new window)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (February 2023) 2023 State of Development Summary Report (pdf, 887kb)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (August 2023) 2023 State of Development Final Report (pdf, 7.2mb)

Keep Victoria Falls Wild (September 2023a) Spotlight on Baines Restaurant. 11th September (revised). (pdf)

Roberts, P. (2026) Paradise Lost? Conservation and Development of the Victoria Falls (1900-2025). First Edition, February 2026. Zambezi Book Company / CreateSpace Independent Publishing.

Scanner Investments (July 2022) Respondent’s Opposing Affidavit. Paperwork relating to restaurant development (inluding concession contract and EIA). (pdf download [114 mb], opens in a new window).

State Parties (2007) 2007-2012 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya Joint Integrated Management Plan (external download, opens in a new window).

State Parties (2016) 2016 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya State of Conservation Report and 2016-2021 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya Joint Integrated Management Plan (external download, opens in a new window).

State Parties (2020) 2020 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya State of Conservation Report (external download, opens in a new window).

State Parties (2021) 2021-30 Strategic Environmental and Social Impact Assessment Report, Victoria Falls World Heritage Property (pdf download [9 mb], opens in a new window)

State Parties (2022) 2021 Victoria Falls/Mosi-oa-Tunya State of Conservation Report (external download, opens in a new window).

UNESCO (2010) Conservation Issues [Online source: https://whc.unesco.org/en/ soc/481]

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (20th March 2019) $500m investment for Victoria Falls... International hotel chain to set up exclusive leisure centre.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (26th December 2020) Lamcent Capital to build US$40m hotel in Vic Falls.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (8th February 2021) Zambezi River Scenes Which Inspired Livingstone Under Threat.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (17th February 2021) Campaign to Save Siansimba Gains Momentum.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (25th February 2021) ZimParks Under Pressure.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (8th June 2022) Cataract Island Tours Threaten Victoria Falls World Heritage Status.

Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (28th June 2022) New US$50m riverside hotel development for Victoria Falls.

Victoria Falls Investments (June 2022) Statement by Victoria Falls Investments on our Restaurant Site Development. (pdf download [167 kb], opens in a new window)

World Heritage Committee (2017) Decisions Adopted, 41COM 7B.22.

Zambezi Crescent (2022) Publicity information, Cataract Pools, April 2022.

Zimbabwe High Court (16th May 2025) Summons. In the matter between Scanner Investments (PVT) Ltd and Lawrence Benjamin Norton. HCH2294/25. Judicial Service Commission.

Zimbabwe Independent (29th July 2022) Dogfight over Victoria Falls.

Zimbabwe Independent (5th August 2022) Praz disowns Vic Falls project.

Zimbabwe Independent (7th February 2025) Govt faces fresh lawsuit over Victoria Falls tourism facility.

Zimbabwe Independent (30th May 2025) Battle to protect Vic Falls: Wildlife artist pushes back... as hospitality firm slaps campaigner with US$2m lawsuit.

Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority (June 2021a) Application (former Railway Water-Pump Station, Victoria Falls Long Term Lease. Letter from Dr F U Mangwanya, Director-General, ZPWMA, 22 June 2021 (jpg download [312 kb], opens in a new window).

Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority (June 2021b) Guidelines for the Establishment of New Semi-Permanent Structures in the Mosi-os-Tunya/Victoria Falls World Heritage Property (pdf download [2.88 mb], opens in a new window).

Zimbabwe Parks and Wildlife Management Authority (October 2023) Zambezi/Victoria Falls National Park General Management Plan (2024-2034). October 2023 (approved April 2024). (pdf download [8mb], opens in a new window)